The Duke Lacrosse Case: Charges Dropped, Players Declared Innocent, Prosecutor Disbarred

Outcome classification
Dismissal

Charges or claims were dismissed, withdrawn, discontinued or not pursued (for example dismissal by a court, nolle prosequi, or a "no further action" decision). Reasons vary and are stated where known. A dismissal is not, on its own, a finding that the allegation was false.

How we classify outcomes
Court
Durham County Superior Court; North Carolina State Bar Disciplinary Hearing Commission
Case number
State of North Carolina v. Seligmann, Finnerty and Evans (Durham County); State Bar disciplinary proceeding against Michael B. Nifong (2007)
Outcome
All charges dismissed by North Carolina's attorney general in April 2007, who said the three players were innocent; District Attorney Mike Nifong was disbarred and held in criminal contempt.
Jurisdiction
Year
,

Last reviewed: · Updated · Drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources below

1Case overview

After a team party in Durham, North Carolina, on March 13, 2006, a woman hired to perform as an exotic dancer alleged that she had been sexually assaulted by members of Duke University's lacrosse team (CNN; CNN, 31 Aug 2007). Durham County District Attorney Mike Nifong charged three players, Reade Seligmann, Collin Finnerty and David Evans, with rape, sexual offense and kidnapping (WRAL).

The rape charge was dropped in December 2006. On April 11, 2007, after the attorney general's office had taken over the case, Attorney General Roy Cooper dismissed all remaining charges and said the three were innocent (CNN; CNN transcript). Nifong was disbarred in June 2007 and held in criminal contempt in August 2007 (WRAL; CNN).

2People & parties involved

  • Reade Seligmann Duke student; charged and later cleared
  • Collin Finnerty Duke student; charged and later cleared
  • David Evans Duke student; charged and later cleared
  • Michael B. Nifong Durham County District Attorney; prosecutor (disbarred 2007)
  • Roy Cooper North Carolina Attorney General; dismissed the charges in April 2007

3Original allegations

The woman alleged that she was sexually assaulted at the party. The three players were initially charged with first-degree forcible rape, first-degree sexual offense and first-degree kidnapping (CNN). The rape charge was dropped in December 2006 after the accuser told prosecutors she could no longer say for certain that one element of the offense had occurred (CNN).

Early in the case Nifong made public comments, including that he would not allow Durham to become known for "a bunch of lacrosse players from Duke raping a black girl" (WRAL).

4Response from the accused

The three players and their lawyers contested the charges. At Nifong's disciplinary hearing, players' parents testified about the strain on their families. "Nobody can give any of the three families back the 14 months we have gone through," Mary Ellen Finnerty said (WRAL).

5Timeline of events

  1. 2006-03-13
    Lacrosse team party in Durham at which the alleged assault was said to have occurred. Source
  2. 2006-12
    The rape charge is dropped; sexual-offense and kidnapping charges remain. Source
  3. 2007-01-13
    Attorney General Roy Cooper accepts Nifong's request to take over the case. Source
  4. 2007-04-11
    Cooper dismisses all charges and says the three players are innocent. Source
  5. 2007-06-16
    The North Carolina State Bar's Disciplinary Hearing Commission disbars Nifong. Source
  6. 2007-08-31
    A Superior Court judge holds Nifong in criminal contempt and sentences him to one day in jail. Source

6Publicly documented evidence

  • DNA. DNA profiles found on the accuser came from unidentified males and did not match any of the 46 lacrosse team members (CNN).
  • The attorney general's review. Cooper said that "no DNA confirms the accuser's story," that "no other witness confirms her story," that "other evidence contradicts her story," and that the eyewitness identification procedures were "faulty and unreliable." He also cited conflicts with photographs and phone records (CNN transcript).
  • Withheld evidence. The State Bar found that Nifong failed to turn over DNA test results that identified genetic material from several men, none of them team members (WRAL).

7Court proceedings

Nifong asked the attorney general to take over the case after the State Bar filed ethics charges against him. Cooper accepted on January 13, 2007, and filed notices of dismissal of all charges on April 11, 2007 (CNN transcript; CNN).

The State Bar's three-member Disciplinary Hearing Commission heard five days of testimony in June 2007 (WRAL). Superior Court Judge W. Osmond Smith III later held a criminal-contempt hearing (CNN).

8Judicial findings & verdicts

Attorney general (April 11, 2007): "Based on the significant inconsistencies between the evidence and the various accounts given by the accusing witness, we believe these three individuals are innocent of these charges ... we have no credible evidence that an attack occurred in that house on that night" (CNN transcript; statement).

State Bar (June 16, 2007): The commission unanimously disbarred Nifong, finding conduct involving "dishonesty, fraud, deceit and misrepresentation." Chairman F. Lane Williamson said: "We acknowledge the actual innocence of the defendants" (WRAL).

Criminal contempt (August 31, 2007): Judge Smith found Nifong in criminal contempt for his handling of the DNA evidence and statements to the court, and sentenced him to one day in jail (CNN).

9Subsequent developments

The allegations led to the cancellation of the team's season and cost coach Mike Pressler his job (CNN). Cooper proposed legislation that would let the state Supreme Court remove a case from a prosecutor in limited circumstances (CNN transcript).

Analysis & context

The Duke lacrosse case is one of the few in which a state’s chief law-enforcement officer did more than drop charges. He publicly declared the accused “innocent.” North Carolina Attorney General Roy Cooper attributed the case to “a tragic rush to accuse and a failure to verify serious allegations” (CNN transcript, 11 Apr 2007).

This profile does not name the woman who made the allegation. Cooper declined to bring charges against her and said investigators believed she “may actually believe the many different stories that she has been telling” (CNN transcript). The documented wrongdoing in this case was found against the prosecutor, by the State Bar and by a judge.

Why this profile is classified as a Dismissal. The charges were dismissed by the attorney general. His statement that the defendants were innocent is unusually strong, but it was an executive decision, not a court verdict.

10Sources & references