These standards govern everything The False Allegation Project publishes, whether it is written by a person or drafted with the help of software. Our aim is to be accurate, fair to everyone named and clear about the difference between what has been alleged and what has been proved.
1. Core principles
- Allegations are not facts. We always attribute allegations to the person who made them, using words such as “alleged”, “accused”, “claimed” or “testified”, until a court or other competent body has made a finding.
- Outcomes are not all the same. An acquittal, a dismissal or a decision not to prosecute does not show that an allegation was false. We never describe an allegation as “false” or “fabricated” unless the record supports that word.
- Presumption of innocence. A person who has been accused, charged or sued but not convicted or found liable is presumed innocent, and we write about them that way.
- Fairness to accusers. Someone whose allegation was not proved has not, for that reason alone, lied. We describe accusers with the same care as the accused.
- Willingness to challenge narratives. When the court record contradicts the popular account of a case, in either direction, we say so and show the evidence.
2. Outcome classifications
Every case profile carries exactly one classification. It describes the legal outcome as of the “last reviewed” date and is not our opinion of who was telling the truth. If a case involved several proceedings, we use the classification that best reflects the most authoritative final decision and explain any conflicting results in the profile.
| Classification | What it means | What it does not mean |
|---|---|---|
| Proven Fabrication | The allegation has been conclusively shown to be knowingly invented. Examples: the accuser was convicted of false reporting, perjury or perverting the course of justice; the accuser made a sworn admission of fabrication; or conclusive objective evidence, acknowledged by a court or prosecutor, disproved the allegation. | A conviction or admission about one allegation does not extend to other allegations unless the record says so. |
| Judicial Finding of Falsity | A judge or tribunal made an express finding of fact that the allegation was false or fabricated, for example in a civil or family-court judgment. | It is not a criminal conviction. It is usually decided on the balance of probabilities. |
| Defamation Verdict | A court or jury in a defamation case decided whether specific published statements about the allegations were false and defamatory, or substantially true. | It is not a criminal finding about the underlying events. Courts in different cases or countries can reach different results, and we report all of them. |
| Acquittal | The accused was found not guilty at a criminal trial. | It shows that guilt was not proved beyond reasonable doubt. It is not, on its own, a finding that the allegation was false. |
| Dismissal | Charges or claims were dismissed, withdrawn, discontinued or not pursued. | Cases are dropped for many reasons, including lack of evidence, witness decisions or procedural grounds. It is not, on its own, a finding that the allegation was false. |
| Disputed | The parties give materially conflicting accounts, and no court or official body has resolved the central question. | We take no side on a disputed case. We present both accounts and the evidence. |
| Unsubstantiated | An investigating body, such as the police, a child-protection agency or a workplace or campus investigator, found insufficient evidence to support the allegation. | “Unsubstantiated” means not proven. It does not mean proven false. |
| Unresolved | Proceedings are ongoing, the outcome is not public, or the matter ended without any decision. | The profile will be updated as the record develops. |
3. Sourcing rules
- Hierarchy of sources. Court judgments, orders, verdict forms and transcripts come first. Then court filings, which we always describe as one party’s claims. Then official statements from police, prosecutors and agencies. Then reporting by established news organizations. Then everything else. Social media posts, forums and anonymous sources are never enough on their own to establish a fact.
- Link everything. Every factual claim in a profile links to its source, and every profile ends with a numbered list of sources. Where a primary document is publicly available, we link to it.
- Quote courts accurately. We quote findings word for word where we can, and we state the standard of proof that applied.
- Record the dates. Every profile shows when it was published, when it was last updated and when its facts were last checked against the sources.
- No sealed or unlawfully obtained material. We do not publish sealed records, material that a court has ordered kept confidential, or material obtained by hacking, deception or other unlawful means.
4. Private individuals, family courts and minors
The risk of serious harm is greatest for people who never chose public life. The following rules apply in addition to everything above.
- Human review is mandatory. No profile or article that involves a private individual, a family-court proceeding or a minor is published or scheduled until a human editor has reviewed and approved it. Our publishing system enforces this automatically.
- Minors are never identified. We do not publish the names, images, schools or other identifying details of children, including children who made or were the subject of allegations.
- Family proceedings. We report on family-court matters only where a judgment or finding has been lawfully published, or where the parties themselves have made the matter public. We follow all reporting restrictions, and where anonymity is required or appropriate we use initials or descriptions.
- Private accusers and accused. We name a private person only when they are already identified in a public court record or in established news reporting, and their name is necessary to understand the case. Otherwise we anonymize. We never publish home addresses, contact details, medical records or financial account information.
- Right of reply. Before publishing a profile that makes significant new claims about a living private person, we make reasonable efforts to contact them, or their lawyer, and we include their response.
- Time and relevance. We will consider requests to anonymize or update old profiles about private individuals where continued identification no longer serves the public interest.
5. Use of automation and AI
We use software, including AI language models, to monitor court dockets and news sources, find new developments, organize timelines, suggest related cases and prepare first drafts. These tools make mistakes. Our rules:
- Every claim in an AI-assisted draft must link to a source that was actually retrieved and checked. Nothing may be included from a model’s “memory”.
- AI-assisted profiles are labelled as such on the page.
- Automated publishing is limited to cases involving public figures in which a court or prosecutor has reached an outcome and the profile cites sources. Everything else waits for a human editor.
- AI tools may not choose or change a case’s outcome classification to a stronger category, such as Proven Fabrication, without a human editor’s approval.
- Every automated profile is held to the same corrections process and the same editorial responsibility as any other.
6. Language
- We use neutral verbs: “said”, “testified”, “alleged”, “found”, “ruled”.
- We do not call anyone a “liar”, “abuser”, “predator” or “fabricator” unless we are quoting a court’s finding, and then we attribute the words to the court.
- Headlines must be supported by the profile and must not go further than the outcome classification.
- We avoid graphic detail that is not needed to understand the evidence.
7. Updates and corrections
Cases change: appeals succeed, verdicts are overturned, new evidence emerges. We update profiles when the record changes, record each development in the timeline and change the classification when the outcome changes. Errors are handled under our Corrections Policy.
8. Conflicts of interest
Contributors must disclose any personal, financial or legal connection to a case or its parties, and must not work on that case. We do not accept payment from parties to cover, remove or change a profile.