The Central Park Five: Convictions Vacated After a Confession and DNA Match

Outcome classification
Dismissal

Charges or claims were dismissed, withdrawn, discontinued or not pursued (for example dismissal by a court, nolle prosequi, or a "no further action" decision). Reasons vary and are stated where known. A dismissal is not, on its own, a finding that the allegation was false.

How we classify outcomes
Court
Supreme Court of the State of New York, New York County (Justice Charles J. Tejada)
Case number
People v. Wise et al. (N.Y. Sup. Ct., New York County); convictions vacated December 19, 2002
Outcome
Convictions vacated and charges dismissed in December 2002 after a serial rapist's confession was confirmed by DNA; New York City settled the men's civil suits for $41 million in 2014.
Jurisdiction
Year
,

Last reviewed: · Updated · Drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources below

1Case overview

Early on April 20, 1989, a 28-year-old woman who had been jogging was found gravely injured in Central Park, New York. Within days, five teenagers aged 14 to 16 (Antron McCray, Kevin Richardson, Yusef Salaam, Raymond Santana and Korey Wise) had implicated themselves after hours of police questioning. They were convicted despite inconsistent confessions, DNA evidence that excluded them, and no eyewitness linking them to the victim (PBS).

On December 19, 2002, Justice Charles J. Tejada of the New York Supreme Court vacated the convictions after Matias Reyes, a serial rapist, confessed and DNA confirmed his account (PBS; The New York Times, 20 Dec 2002). In 2014 New York City settled the men's civil suits for $41 million (The New York Times, 6 Sep 2014).

2People & parties involved

  • Antron McCray Arrested at 15; conviction vacated 2002
  • Kevin Richardson Arrested at 14; conviction vacated 2002
  • Yusef Salaam Arrested at 15; conviction vacated 2002
  • Raymond Santana Arrested at 14; conviction vacated 2002
  • Korey Wise Arrested at 16; conviction vacated 2002
  • Matias Reyes Convicted serial rapist who confessed to the attack in 2002; his DNA matched the evidence

3Original allegations

Police told the press that the teenagers had been part of a group "wilding" in the park that night, assaulting joggers and cyclists. The confessions were the core of the case against them, and coverage of the arrests was intense (PBS).

4Response from the accused

The five later said their statements were the product of hours of psychological pressure and aggressive interrogation (PBS). After the convictions were vacated they sued the city, the police officers and the prosecutors involved (PBS).

5Timeline of events

  1. 1989-04-20
    The jogger is found gravely injured in Central Park; five teenagers are arrested within days. Source
  2. 2002-01
    Matias Reyes, a convicted murderer and rapist, comes forward and says he attacked the jogger alone. Source
  3. 2002-12-19
    Justice Charles J. Tejada vacates the convictions after Matias Reyes's confession and a DNA match. Source
  4. 2003
    The five file civil suits against New York City, police officers and prosecutors. Source
  5. 2014-09-05
    A federal judge approves the city's $41 million settlement. Source

6Publicly documented evidence

  • DNA. DNA evidence presented at the original trials excluded the five. In 2002 DNA matched Reyes (PBS).
  • Confession. Reyes, already convicted of murder and rape, came forward in January 2002. He was linked to the rape "by DNA and other evidence" (The New York Times).
  • The original confessions. PBS describes them as "inconsistent and inaccurate" (PBS).

7Court proceedings

The five were tried and convicted. After Reyes came forward in January 2002, defense lawyers and Manhattan District Attorney Robert M. Morgenthau moved to vacate all of the convictions, including those for robberies and assaults in the park that night. Justice Tejada granted the motions on December 19, 2002. An assistant district attorney then immediately moved to dismiss the indictments rather than seek a new trial (The New York Times; PBS).

The civil suits were filed in 2003 and settled in 2014 (PBS; Los Angeles Times).

8Judicial findings & verdicts

The 2002 ruling vacated the convictions on the basis of new evidence identifying Reyes as the probable sole attacker. The indictments were then dismissed on the prosecution's motion (The New York Times). On the day of the ruling, Police Commissioner Raymond W. Kelly publicly challenged Reyes's claim that he had acted alone (The New York Times). It was not a jury acquittal. The city's 2014 settlement was approved without the city accepting blame, as The New York Times reported (The New York Times).

9Subsequent developments

The $41 million settlement was approved on September 5, 2014 (CBS New York; Los Angeles Times). The case has been the subject of documentaries and dramatizations, including Ken Burns's The Central Park Five (PBS).

Analysis & context

The Central Park jogger case is a wrongful-conviction case rather than a case of an invented complaint. The victim of the 1989 attack was real and was gravely injured. She had no memory of the assault, and she never accused the five teenagers (PBS). The accusation against them was built on statements taken from the boys during police interrogation, which the five later disputed.

This profile is included because the convictions were vacated on new evidence: another man’s confession, confirmed by DNA. Readers should be aware that, according to PBS, some police and prosecutors involved in the original case still maintain that the five were guilty (PBS).

Why this profile is classified as a Dismissal. The convictions were vacated and the charges dismissed on the prosecutor’s recommendation. There was no retrial and no acquittal.

10Sources & references