Brian Banks: A Rape Conviction Dismissed After the Accuser Recanted

Outcome classification
Dismissal

Charges or claims were dismissed, withdrawn, discontinued or not pursued (for example dismissal by a court, nolle prosequi, or a "no further action" decision). Reasons vary and are stated where known. A dismissal is not, on its own, a finding that the allegation was false.

How we classify outcomes
Court
Los Angeles County Superior Court (Judge Mark C. Kim)
Case number
People v. Brian Banks (Los Angeles County Superior Court); conviction set aside May 24, 2012
Outcome
Conviction set aside and charges dismissed in May 2012 at the prosecution's request after the accuser recanted on video; the school district later won a $2.6 million default judgment against her.
Jurisdiction
Year
,

Last reviewed: · Updated · Drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources below

1Case overview

On July 8, 2002, Brian Banks, a 16-year-old football player at Polytechnic High School in Long Beach, California, who had verbally accepted a scholarship to the University of Southern California, was accused of raping a 15-year-old classmate on campus. Facing a possible sentence of 41 years to life, he pleaded no contest in July 2003 and was sentenced to six years in prison (National Registry of Exonerations).

In 2011 the accuser contacted Banks and, in a videotaped meeting, said there had been no rape. On May 24, 2012, at the request of the Los Angeles County District Attorney's office, the conviction was set aside and the charges dismissed (National Registry of Exonerations; Los Angeles Times, 24 May 2012).

2People & parties involved

  • Brian Banks Accused; 16 at the time of the allegation; exonerated 2012
  • The accuser (not named here) 15-year-old classmate at the time; later recanted
  • California Innocence Project (Justin Brooks) Represented Banks in the 2011–2012 habeas petition
  • Long Beach Unified School District Settled the accuser's family's lawsuit; later obtained a judgment against the accuser

3Original allegations

The accuser said Banks raped her near a stairwell at the school. The District Attorney charged him in January 2003 with two counts of forcible rape and one count of sodomy, with a kidnapping special circumstance (National Registry of Exonerations).

The accuser's family sued the Long Beach Unified School District, alleging inadequate security. The suit settled for $1.5 million, split evenly between the family and their attorney (National Registry of Exonerations; Los Angeles Times).

4Response from the accused

Banks said the encounter had not been a rape (Los Angeles Times). In 2006 he filed a habeas petition arguing that there was no physical evidence of rape and that his lawyer had been ineffective; it was denied (National Registry of Exonerations).

5Timeline of events

  1. 2002-07-08
    The 15-year-old accuser reports that Banks raped her at Long Beach Polytechnic High School. Source
  2. 2003-07-08
    Banks pleads no contest; he is sentenced to six years in prison. Source
  3. 2011-02-28
    The accuser contacts Banks on Facebook; she later says on video that there was no rape. Source
  4. 2011-08-15
    The California Innocence Project files a habeas petition. Source
  5. 2012-05-24
    Judge Mark C. Kim sets aside the conviction and the charges are dismissed. Source
  6. 2013-06
    Long Beach Unified wins a $2.6 million default judgment against the accuser. Source

6Publicly documented evidence

  • Videotaped recantation. In a videotaped interview the accuser said she and Banks had kissed and fondled but had not had sex. She said she had been afraid to come forward because her family might have to repay the $750,000 they received (National Registry of Exonerations).
  • Statements described in the habeas petition. According to the petition, the accuser had told a classmate two years after the allegation that she had not been raped, and had told her own civil attorney the same thing (National Registry of Exonerations). These are allegations made in a court filing.
  • Physical evidence. No biological evidence that could be tested for DNA was found (National Registry of Exonerations).

7Court proceedings

Banks pleaded no contest in 2003, served five years in prison and was released on parole with an ankle monitor and a requirement to register as a sex offender (National Registry of Exonerations). The California Innocence Project, led by Justin Brooks, brought the new evidence back to Judge Mark C. Kim, who had presided over the original case (Los Angeles Times; Innocence Project).

8Judicial findings & verdicts

At a short hearing on May 24, 2012, a prosecutor conceded the case. The conviction was set aside and the charges dismissed at the request of Deputy District Attorney Brentford Ferreira (Los Angeles Times; National Registry of Exonerations).

In 2013 the Long Beach Unified School District obtained a $2.6 million default judgment against the accuser to recover the settlement plus other sums (Los Angeles Times; CBS News). Because it was a default judgment, the claims were not contested at trial.

9Subsequent developments

In June 2015 the State of California awarded Banks $142,000 in compensation (National Registry of Exonerations).

Analysis & context

The Banks case is one of the better-documented recantation exonerations in the United States. The accuser told Banks on video that no rape had occurred. Prosecutors then agreed to set aside the conviction, which was dismissed in 2012 (National Registry of Exonerations). The National Registry of Exonerations lists “perjury or false accusation” as a contributing factor.

This profile does not name the accuser, who was 15 when the allegation was made. She was not criminally charged. The later civil judgment against her was entered by default (Los Angeles Times, 20 Jun 2013).

Why this profile is classified as a Dismissal. The conviction was set aside and the charges dismissed at the prosecution’s request. Banks had pleaded no contest, so there was never a trial verdict.

10Sources & references

  1. Academic Brian Banks National Registry of Exonerations, 2012-05-29
  2. News Former USC recruit exonerated for 2002 rape Los Angeles Times, 2012-05-24
  3. Other Conviction Dismissed Against Former High School Football Player Innocence Project, 2012-05-24
  4. News Brian Banks' accuser ordered to pay school district $2.6 million Los Angeles Times, 2013-06-20
  5. News Calif. school district wins $2.6M from accuser in "false rape" case CBS News, 2013-06