The Tawana Brawley Case: A Grand Jury Rejects the Accusation and a Prosecutor Wins Defamation Verdict
A court or jury in a defamation case decided whether specific published statements about the allegations were false and defamatory, or substantially true. A defamation verdict concerns particular statements and the civil burden of proof in that case; it is not a criminal finding about the underlying events, and courts in different cases or countries can reach different results.
How we classify outcomes- Court
- Supreme Court of the State of New York, Dutchess County (special grand jury, 1988; civil jury trial, 1997–98)
- Case number
- Pagones v. Maddox, Mason, Sharpton and Brawley (N.Y. Sup. Ct., Dutchess County; filed October 31, 1988)
- Outcome
- A 1988 grand jury concluded the accusations against Steven Pagones were false; in 1998 a jury found Al Sharpton, Alton Maddox and C. Vernon Mason liable for defaming him and awarded $345,000. Brawley lost by default.
- Jurisdiction
- New York
- Categories
- Defamation Litigation, Sexual Assault Allegations
Last reviewed: · Updated · Drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources below
1Case overview
On November 28, 1987, 15-year-old Tawana Brawley was found in a plastic bag behind her family's former apartment in Wappingers Falls, New York, with racial slurs written on her body. She said she had been abducted and raped by a group of white men (The New York Times; CNN). Her advisers, the Rev. Al Sharpton and lawyers Alton H. Maddox Jr. and C. Vernon Mason, publicly accused Dutchess County Assistant District Attorney Steven Pagones of taking part (The New York Times).
A special grand jury concluded in October 1988 that Brawley had not been the victim of a forcible sexual assault and that the allegations against Pagones were false (grand jury report). Pagones sued for defamation. In July 1998 a jury found the three advisers liable, and they were ordered to pay $345,000 (The New York Times; NPR).
2People & parties involved
- Steven A. Pagones Former Dutchess County assistant district attorney; plaintiff (treated as a public official)
- Rev. Al Sharpton Brawley adviser; defendant found liable
- Alton H. Maddox Jr. Brawley adviser and lawyer; defendant found liable
- C. Vernon Mason Brawley adviser and lawyer; defendant found liable
- Tawana Brawley Complainant (15 in 1987); defendant who lost by default
3Original allegations
Brawley said she had been abducted and repeatedly raped over four days by white men (CNN). Her advisers named Pagones as one of the attackers. On a television talk show on March 31, 1988, Sharpton said: "We stated openly that Steven Pagones, the assistant district attorney, did it ... If we're lying, sue us." In a March 1989 speech at Harvard Law School, Mason said Pagones and two other men "raped, kidnapped and sodomized Tawana Brawley" (The New York Times).
4Response from the accused
Pagones denied any involvement. The grand jury found that his testimony, his witnesses and his documentary and photographic evidence were "credible and persuasive" and accounted for his whereabouts for "virtually every hour" of the four days (grand jury report).
After the 1998 verdict Sharpton said: "I didn't believe it to be a hoax then, and I don't believe it to be a hoax now." Maddox said the verdict vindicated his allegations, and the advisers said they would appeal (The New York Times).
5Timeline of events
- 1987-11-28Brawley is found behind 19A Carnaby Drive in the Town of Wappingers, New York. Source
- 1988-03-31On television, Sharpton accuses Pagones and says, "If we're lying, sue us." Source
- 1988-10A special grand jury concludes that no sexual assault occurred and that the allegations against Pagones are false. Source
- 1988-10-31Pagones files a defamation suit against Brawley and her three advisers. Source
- 1991-05A judge rules that Pagones has won by default against Brawley, who never responded. Source
- 1998-07-13A Dutchess County jury finds Sharpton, Maddox and Mason liable for defaming Pagones. Source
- 1998-07The jury orders the advisers to pay a total of $345,000. Source
- 2013-08Pagones begins receiving payments from Brawley through wage garnishment. Source
6Publicly documented evidence
- Grand jury conclusions. "Tawana Brawley was not the victim of a forcible sexual assault by multiple assailants over a four-day period. There is no evidence that any sexual assault occurred." The grand jury also concluded that "there is nothing in regard to Tawana Brawley's appearance on Nov. 28 that is inconsistent with this condition having been self-inflicted" (grand jury report).
- Medical and physical findings. The grand jury found that when she was discovered she was not suffering from exposure or malnourishment, and had no burns although her jeans were burned (grand jury report).
- No cover-up. The grand jury found "no evidence that a cover-up occurred or was attempted" (grand jury report).
7Court proceedings
Pagones filed suit on October 31, 1988, against Brawley and her three advisers. Brawley never responded, and in May 1991 a judge ruled for Pagones against her by default. The trial against the advisers began on November 18, 1997, and lasted nearly eight months. Because Pagones had been an assistant district attorney, the court treated him as a public official, so he had to prove the statements were made knowing they were false or with reckless disregard for the truth (The New York Times).
8Judicial findings & verdicts
On July 13, 1998, the six-person jury found seven defamatory statements by Sharpton, including two it found he knew were false. It found two defamatory statements by Maddox and one by Mason, whose 1989 Harvard speech it found was made knowing it was false. The jury found no defamation in 12 of the 22 statements Pagones had sued over and rejected his conspiracy claim (The New York Times). It then ordered the three to pay Pagones a total of $345,000 (NPR).
9Subsequent developments
CNN reported in 2013 that Sharpton had since paid his share. Brawley, then a nurse living in Virginia, began making payments through wage garnishment but still owed Pagones more than $431,000 (CNN, 4 Aug 2013; NPR, 5 Aug 2013). Pagones said he would forgive the debt if she apologized (CNN).
Analysis & context
The Brawley case is the clearest example in this batch of an official body expressly finding an accusation false. A New York grand jury that investigated the allegations against Assistant District Attorney Steven Pagones concluded that “the unsworn public allegations against … Steven Pagones are false, have no basis in fact” (grand jury report, via The New York Times). A civil jury later found that three of the complainant’s advisers had defamed him.
The complainant was 15 in 1987. She is named here because she was a named defendant in the defamation suit as an adult and lost it by default. She has never testified about her allegations (The New York Times, 14 Jul 1998). The grand jury’s conclusions were reached on a preponderance of the evidence and were not a criminal conviction of anyone.
Why this profile is classified as a Defamation Verdict. The court-resolved outcome is the 1998 jury verdict for Pagones. The grand jury report is a strong official finding, but it is not a judgment of a court.
10Sources & references
- Court record 'We, the Grand Jury': Text of Its Conclusions in the Tawana Brawley Case
- News Brawley Made Rape Story Up, Grand Jury Says
- News Sharpton and 2 Advisers Are Liable in Defamation
- News Pagones To Be Paid 350,000
- News Tawana Brawley starts paying man she falsely accused of rape in 1987
- News 15 Years Later, Tawana Brawley Has Paid 1 Percent Of Penalty