Michael Morton: 25 Years for a Murder DNA Showed He Didn’t Commit, and a Prosecutor Jailed
Charges or claims were dismissed, withdrawn, discontinued or not pursued (for example dismissal by a court, nolle prosequi, or a "no further action" decision). Reasons vary and are stated where known. A dismissal is not, on its own, a finding that the allegation was false.
How we classify outcomes- Court
- Williamson County District Court; Texas Court of Criminal Appeals; Court of Inquiry (2013)
- Case number
- State of Texas v. Michael Morton (Williamson County, Texas); conviction vacated by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals October 12, 2011; case dismissed December 19, 2011
- Outcome
- Conviction vacated in October 2011 and charges dismissed in December 2011 after DNA identified another man, who was convicted in 2013; former prosecutor Ken Anderson was jailed for contempt for withholding evidence.
- Jurisdiction
- Texas
- Categories
- Criminal Proceedings
Last reviewed: · Updated · Drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources below
1Case overview
Christine Morton was beaten to death in her bed in Austin, Texas, on August 13, 1986, after her husband Michael had left for work. Michael Morton was charged with her murder, convicted in February 1987 and sentenced to life in prison (National Registry of Exonerations).
In 2011, DNA testing of a bloodstained bandana found near the home identified another man. Morton was released on October 4, 2011, after nearly 25 years in prison. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals vacated his conviction on October 12, and the case was dismissed on December 19, 2011 (National Registry of Exonerations; Innocence Project).
2People & parties involved
- Michael Morton Convicted of his wife's 1986 murder (1987); exonerated 2011
- Ken Anderson Lead prosecutor at trial; later a district judge; held in criminal contempt in 2013
- Mark Alan Norwood Convicted in 2013 of the murder for which Morton had been imprisoned
- Innocence Project Represented Morton in post-conviction DNA litigation
3Original allegations
The prosecution argued that Morton killed his wife because she had refused to have sex with him on his birthday and then staged the scene to look like a burglary. Its case relied on a note he left her, a rented explicit film and a medical examiner's estimate of the time of death (National Registry of Exonerations).
4Response from the accused
Morton maintained his innocence and testified at trial. He believed an intruder had killed his wife after he left for work (National Registry of Exonerations).
5Timeline of events
- 1986-08-13Christine Morton is found beaten to death in the family home. Source
- 1987-02-17A jury convicts Michael Morton of murder; he is sentenced to life. Source
- 2011-06-30DNA testing finds the victim's blood and an unknown man's DNA on a bandana found near the home. Source
- 2011-10-04Morton is released after nearly 25 years in prison. Source
- 2011-10-12The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals vacates the conviction. Source
- 2011-11-09Another man is arrested and charged with the murder. Source
- 2011-12-19The prosecution dismisses the case against Morton. Source
- 2013-11-08Former prosecutor Ken Anderson is sentenced to 10 days in jail for criminal contempt and agrees to give up his law license. Source
6Publicly documented evidence
- DNA. A blue bandana found about 100 yards from the house carried the victim's blood and hair and DNA from an unknown man. The profile was matched through CODIS to a man with a criminal record in California and Texas (National Registry of Exonerations).
- Withheld evidence. Reports never disclosed to the defense included a transcript of the victim's mother's interview. In it she said the couple's three-year-old son, who was present during the murder, had said his father was "not home." Other undisclosed reports concerned a man seen parking a green van behind the house and the use of the victim's credit card after her death (National Registry of Exonerations).
- Prosecutor's assurance. Before trial, lead prosecutor Ken Anderson assured the court that all exculpatory evidence had been given to the defense (National Registry of Exonerations).
7Court proceedings
Morton's conviction was affirmed on appeal in 1988. The Innocence Project sought further DNA testing from 2005, and in 2010 an appeals court ordered the bandana tested (National Registry of Exonerations). At the request of Morton's lawyers, a Court of Inquiry examined Anderson's conduct and in April 2013 found that he should face criminal contempt and tampering charges (National Registry of Exonerations).
8Judicial findings & verdicts
The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals vacated Morton's conviction on October 12, 2011 (National Registry of Exonerations). The man identified by the DNA was convicted of Christine Morton's murder in March 2013 and sentenced to life (National Registry of Exonerations).
On November 8, 2013, Anderson entered a plea to criminal contempt for deliberately withholding exculpatory evidence. He received 10 days in jail, a $500 fine and 500 hours of community service, and he surrendered his law license (Innocence Project). He had resigned his judgeship in September 2013 (National Registry of Exonerations).
9Subsequent developments
Morton received $1.9 million in state compensation plus a monthly annuity (National Registry of Exonerations). At Anderson's sentencing, Judge Kelly G. Moore told Morton: "the world is a better place because of you" (Innocence Project).
Analysis & context
The Morton case is a wrongful conviction caused by official misconduct, not a false complaint by an accuser. It is included because the accusation against Morton, made by the State of Texas, was shown by DNA evidence to be wrong. It is also one of the very few cases in which a prosecutor has been criminally punished for withholding evidence. The Innocence Project called it “perhaps the first time” that had happened (Innocence Project, 8 Nov 2013).
Why this profile is classified as a Dismissal. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals vacated the conviction and the prosecution then dismissed the case. Another man was later convicted of the murder.