Case Database
This database collects publicly documented cases involving false, fabricated, exaggerated, disputed or weaponized allegations. Search by name, court or keyword, or filter by category, outcome and year. Each case is classified by its outcome under our published definitions. An acquittal or a dismissal is not, on its own, proof that an allegation was false, so we label each outcome exactly.
Start with our in-depth case study: the Craig Matthew Feigin case.
9 cases
The Tawana Brawley Case: A Grand Jury Rejects the Accusation and a Prosecutor Wins Defamation Verdict
A 1988 grand jury concluded the accusations against Steven Pagones were false; in 1998 a jury found Al Sharpton, Alton Maddox and C. Vernon Mason liable for defaming him and awarded $345,000.…
Michael Morton: 25 Years for a Murder DNA Showed He Didn’t Commit, and a Prosecutor Jailed
Conviction vacated in October 2011 and charges dismissed in December 2011 after DNA identified another man, who was convicted in 2013; former prosecutor Ken Anderson was jailed for contempt for withholding evidence.
Brian Banks: A Rape Conviction Dismissed After the Accuser Recanted
Conviction set aside and charges dismissed in May 2012 at the prosecution's request after the accuser recanted on video; the school district later won a $2.6 million default judgment against her.
The Central Park Five: Convictions Vacated After a Confession and DNA Match
Convictions vacated and charges dismissed in December 2002 after a serial rapist's confession was confirmed by DNA; New York City settled the men's civil suits for $41 million in 2014.
The Duke Lacrosse Case: Charges Dropped, Players Declared Innocent, Prosecutor Disbarred
All charges dismissed by North Carolina's attorney general in April 2007, who said the three players were innocent; District Attorney Mike Nifong was disbarred and held in criminal contempt.
Eramo v. Rolling Stone: The Retracted ‘A Rape on Campus’ Story and the $3 Million Verdict
A federal jury found Rolling Stone, its publisher and reporter Sabrina Rubin Erdely liable for defaming UVA dean Nicole Eramo with actual malice and awarded $3 million (2016); the case later settled.
Richard Jewell: The Olympic Park Hero Named as a Bombing Suspect, Then Cleared
Never charged; federal prosecutors formally cleared Jewell in October 1996, and Eric Rudolph later pleaded guilty to the bombing.
The Narrative Came First: How a $3.99 E-book Became a “Spyware” Case Against Craig Matthew Feigin That the Record Does Not Support
In state court, a video-voyeurism count was not prosecuted and other computer counts were closed without trial; the principal computer case was transferred for federal prosecution, and Feigin says he later pleaded…
Depp v. Heard and Depp v. News Group Newspapers: Two Defamation Cases, Two Different Results
London judge found The Sun's "wife beater" article substantially true (2020); Virginia jury found Heard's op-ed defamed Depp and that Depp's lawyer defamed Heard (2022); settled December 2022.
About this database. Profiles are built from court records, published judgments and established news reporting, and each one shows the date it was last reviewed. Inclusion here does not mean that anyone named committed a crime or made a false report, unless a court has found that. If you see an error, please request a correction.
